The Retro Scaredy Cat is here to prowl your Halloween collection with that classic, wide-eyed expression of surprise that never gets old. This little 6-inch paper mache lantern by Rachel Garrison captures the spirit of vintage Halloween decor with its dramatic features and unmistakable old-school vibes.

Its deep-set eyes look out in surprise, and its vellum inserts allow a flickering glow to shine through when you insert a battery-operated tea light. The brilliant orange nose and streaks down the muzzle add just the proper amount of color, like the last brushstrokes on a haunted canvas.

Around the base, a ring of crinkled orange and black crepe festooning gives this black cat a burst of old-fashioned flair, perfect for a Halloween display that leans into those spooky retro roots. The wide, toothy grin, framed with bold red and white stripes, adds a bit of playful fear, as if this cat just spotted a ghost or perhaps caught a glimpse of its own shadow.

Combine it with additional lanterns, Halloween buckets, or a few flickering candles to create a sentimental setting that exudes October spirit. This Retro Scaredy Cat will stand out as a daring, whimsical homage to earlier Halloweens, whether it is sitting on a side table, watching over a stack of candy, or peering out from a shelf. If you love a bit of spook mixed with a whole lot of style, this cat’s for you. Just don’t be surprised if it gets a little jumpy when the lights go out.